Time and Punishment
Crackshot
Beat Marisol at shooting
Gunslinger
Beat Marisol at shooting on your first try
Sharpshooter
Beat Marisol at shooting on your first try...with a perfect score (and without practicing)
Heck of A Hangover
Stop the bar brawl by smashing a bottle over the thug's head
Once Upon A Time In Western Vespuccia
Complete the game
Duck, You Sucker!
Knock Jem out
The Magnificent Six
Get all high relationship companion excursions in one playthrough
Bloodthirsty
Picked Phil's plan for the wagon raid
Sneaky
Picked Nadine's plan for the wagon raid
Theatrical
Picked Jake's plan for the wagon raid
Master Bluffer
Keep Jake's bluff going as long as possible
Burn It To The Ground
Straight and Narrow
Convinced Jem to give up his criminal ways
A Fistful of Crowns
Earned 200 crowns or more in one playthrough
Cat Nap
Drugged the wildcat
Union Man
Enter the Jolly Good Club with Phil's help
Rough Justice
Enter the Jolly Good Club with Danny's help
Dr. Redbird: Medicine Woman
Enter the Jolly Good Club with Nadine's help
Brute Force
Stinky
Woman of Many Hats
Special Delivery
Exorcised the Demons
Successfully helped Captain Boylan
Heck of a Show
Fully helped Miss Hatomi's troupe
Off the Mountain
Escaped New Bethel
Bullet Time
Danny helped get rid of the guard
Potion Master
Nadine helped get rid of the guard
Ghost of a Chance
Phil helped get rid of the guard
Outsmarted the Trickster
Got the stick back from the coyote
The Good, The Bad, and the Fluffy
Stargazer
Correctly identify all constellations without any mistakes
The Last Traitor
Deal with Hernandez
Buzzkill
Got the bandits to leave by shooting the wasp nest
Heroic
Save the kid at the river
Gratuitous Nudity
Tables Turned
Outsmart the scammer
Master Hunter
Shoot all the pheasants
Fish Story
Catch all the fish
Good Samaritan
Tradition Observer
Write something on the boulder
A Great Man
Moving On
Help Danny with the memorial
The Sign of the Coyote
Help the sick coyote
Initiate
Perform the labor union initiation correctly on your first try
Loose-Lipped
Get the Fortuyn family to open up
Tongue Twister
You succeeded at Phil's challenge
Locksmith
Pick every lock in the game in a single playthrough
"Current" Events
Some Hard Feelings
You punched Jake
The Journey Begins
Set off across Western Vespuccia
I Left My Heart in El Presidio
Arrive in El Presidio
Desperate Times
Pawned one of your companions' belongings
Close Call
Phil disarmed the bomb
Good Listener
Let Martha handle Mr. Sirkas
Oil's Well That Ends Well
Saved Cormac
Not in the Cards
Expose Lady Tyché's operation
In Rain, Sleet, or Snow...
Saved the post office
Fossil Hunter
Successfully tagged 5 fossils
Say That Again
What a literal turn of mind you have
Wily Coyote, Super Genius
He's not very bright
Jokester
Phil appreciates your sense of humor
Flor Silvestre
A campfire is always nicer with music
Confession
Teetotaler
Just said no